Psychoeducation Series #2: (Why) Am I Depressed?

We all wonder from time to time if we or a loved one is depressed, and why we are so. Let me try to shed some light on these questions.

Clinically there are several types of depression, but there are two types therapists usually work with; Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), and Persistent Depressive Disorder (PDD), also called Dysthymia. (PDD is basically a less intense but much longer lasting version of MDD.) Here I will focus on MDD, but a lot of what I say can be applied to PDD.

 

Some therapists use tools such as the well-regarded Beck Depression Inventory to help diagnose Depression, but the cornerstone of diagnosis is the DSM-5, so let’s look at the official diagnostic criteria for adults. If you think you see yourself in there, or even if you think you might, by all means see a mental health professional!

**And if you are even thinking about suicide please don’t do it.

Please call 911 or the national suicide prevention lifeline immediately. They even have chat!**

 

For MDD it’s a two-part diagnosis. First, you must have either a depressed mood, or loss of interest or pleasure from nearly all activities, or both, for at least 2 weeks.

Depressed mood refers to feeling sad, empty, or hopeless most of the day, nearly every day, from your own point of view or as observed by others. The loss of interest and pleasure, dysphoria, is to me to be the core depression; people generally seem to feel more pained by it than by experiencing a down mood.

The second part of the official criteria for MDD is that you have to have at least 4 of the following 7 symptoms.

  1. Gaining or losing a lot of weight, like more than 5% of your body weight in a month without dieting, or having a decrease or increase in appetite nearly every day;

  2. Insomnia or hypersomnia nearly every day;

  3. Others see you as being restless or slowed down, every day, not just from your own POV;

  4. Fatigue or loss of energy nearly every day;

  5. Feeling worthless or inappropriately guilty nearly every day – not just feeling guilty or being upset with yourself, or feeling guilty, but much stronger feelings, even up to delusions about your worthlessness;

  6. Being less able to think or concentrate, or being indecisive, nearly every day – either in your own POV or as observed by others;

  7. Recurrent thoughts of death (not just fear of dying), recurrently imagining suicide without a plan, or developing a plan for suicide, or attempting suicide

Beyond that, like with pretty much any diagnosis, the symptoms a person is experiencing have to be causing significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning, and the episode can’t be better attributed to substance use or another medical condition.

If you think you see yourself in there, or even if you think you might, by all means see a mental health professional! 

Now let’s try to understand it better. Depression stems from your beliefs about yourself, your goals, and your appraisal of what a situation ultimately means. More specifically, I tell my patients that at its core, depression is anger turned inward. Let me explain by using eminent psychologist Richard Lazarus’ theory of emotions as appraisals, which is at the core of how I do therapy.

A person finds themselves in a situation with painful, even dour or dire consequences. Job loss, a relationship ending, a major health problem – all of these losses and many others make us feel sad. There’s nothing abnormal about feeling sad due to them, and many people experience them without going into Depression.

But what makes one person’s lament another person’s depression? What we think and feel about what the loss means – about us and for us.

A healthy sadness allows us to process that a loss is permanent. In healthy sadness, the ideas, people, and relationships we are committed to are lost to us but there is no one to blame. The healthily sad person correctly appraises that the loss cannot be stopped or reversed; they are helpless to do anything about it and become resigned to it. The loss causes a temporary loss of engagement with things and people, but eventually the distress disappears because the person fully gave up their lost commitment and has hope for replacements.

Depression is a much more negative appraisal. Rather than being honestly and correctly helpless about a blameless loss, sometimes a person becomes hopeless due to their loss. They become hopeless about being able to withstand the lost connection and about their ability to gain new ones – ultimately because they believe there was something fundamental about them that caused the catastrophic loss or failure. They then turn to punish themselves. This is anger turned inward.

In depression, you don’t just get sad from losing your job, status, or partner, you appraise that it was some deep flaw(s) of yours that led them away, and that since those flaws are fundamental to you, you’ve made it so that your future is damned. In the words of one of my psychological heroes, Alfred Adler (the creator of Adlerian psychology), you “act, think, and feel in such a way as if the horrible fate you have conjured up had already befallen you and was inevitable.”

It’s painful to give up on our commitments, especially the ones we come to feel define us. But it’s a little easier to choose to see that even a great loss doesn’t have to be one that destroys the meaning in your life. I bet you can see that among the people you know who have experienced major losses, those who have more commitments in their lives outside the one they lost get sad, but are less likely to become depressed.

In sum, depression means deciding, consciously or unconsciously, that you cannot resign yourself to a specific loss, choosing not to pay attention to the fact that you have many other valuable commitments that define you, likely concluding that you caused the loss, and need to be punished for it.

Getting out of depression is about consciously accepting that you cannot repair your loss, but that you do have other valuable commitments or that you can create them if you choose, and that you aren’t doomed because of some fact about you.

Loss always hurts, but the wound doesn’t have to be grave. Your beliefs about yourself and your goals are the deciding factors.

Recent Articles

  • How to Get Better at Boundaries: Use Healthy Negotiating Principles

    This is especially useful when you think about the implicit negotiations in creating and maintaining healthy boundaries with people. Healthy boundaries, after all, are all about mutual respect for one another’s wants and needs, and awareness of what is and isn’t your responsibility. Here are six useful lessons to consider.

    Read More
  • Influencers #5: Aristotle on Deliberation, Choice, and Emotion

    I previously explained that Plato realized that if we could figure out how the living body of a being registers stimuli, it would go a long way toward us understanding how the more intelligent system, the perceptive consciousness of a human, works.

    Read More
  • Influencers #4: Aristotle Forms Psychology Into A Science

    If you kept up with my series on Plato starting psychology as a serious pursuit, you’ll recall that one of his most important contributions was creating a structure for thinking about the nature of the emotions and understanding how central they are to intelligent action.

    Read More
  • Influencers #3: Embodying Plato’s Psychology

    Did you ever think how strange it must have been to be an infant? Spending your few waking hours drooling, blurry-eyed, unable to fathom object permanence, and lacking much working memory or recognition of anything beyond some chemical identification your primary caregivers?

    Read More
  • Influencers #2: Understanding Plato’s Psychology

    I previously explained that Plato realized that if we could figure out how the living body of a being registers stimuli, it would go a long way toward us understanding how the more intelligent system, the perceptive consciousness of a human, works.

    Read More
  • Influencers #1: Plato Begins Psychology

    Plato accepted the basic position of his predecessors that thinking and emotions come from the same physical system, and that the physicality of cognition is invaluable

    Read More
  • Psychoeducation Series #4: A Deeper Understanding of Anxiety

    The oft-noted phenomenon “What You Allow is What Will Continue” is closely related; we often see people treating us in ways we don’t like or want, yet are unwilling to say or hold our boundaries. In both there is a certain laxness involved, and thinking with either of these mental errors contributes mightily to anxiety.

    Read More
  • Psychoeducation Series #3: Anxiety – Why Me?

    Can we ever really get rid of anxiety? In this two part series I’ll discuss anxiety generally and give some tips on how to try to manage it, then I will give you a deeper theoretical dive into the two related but usefully different ways I conceptualize it in treatment. The very short answer to …

    Read More
  • Psychoeducation Series #2: (Why) Am I Depressed?

    We all wonder from time to time if we or a loved one is depressed, and why we are so. Let me try to shed some light on these questions. Clinically there are several types of depression, but there are two types therapists usually work with; Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), and Persistent Depressive Disorder (PDD), …

    Read More
  • Psychoeducation Series #1: Why Am I Angry?

    Saying someone is ‘emotional’ is usually meant as something of a criticism, but the truth is humans would never have evolved if we didn’t have emotions. They have played an indelible, irreplaceable role in our evolution as a species, and in the development of our societies. While emotions such as love and fear are bedrock …

    Read More
  • What To Expect In Psychotherapy

    As a psychotherapist, I find it troubling that there are so many badly dramatized depictions of therapy in TV and film. (One *good* one is the show In Treatment). I imagine it’s better than being a lawyer and having to deal with the negative stereotypes and jokes, but the state of affairs leaves most people …

    Read More
  • Welcome To My Blog

    In these pages I’ll discuss with you influential philosophers, psychologists, theories, and their practical applications with the goal of helping you better understand yourself, the puzzles, and the roadblocks you may be facing. Happy reading!

    Read More